$6.59 .com Sale at GoDaddy.com
MacHits
AppleTell

Related tags

iPod (8) iPhone (6) Business (3) iPod touch (2) iPod classic (2) Accessories (2) iPod nano (1) iPhone SDK (1) iTunes (1)

Will the iPhone kill iPod Click Wheel gaming?

July 16, 2008

Section: iPod + iTunes, iPod touch, iPod Family, iTunes, iPod, iPod nano, iPhone + Communications, iPhone, iPhone SDK & Apps, Originals

iPod Click Wheel GamingYes, and it’s about time we put it out of its misery. Even before the iPhone, the iPod never stood a chance as a legitimate gaming device. This saddens me somewhat, too, because I really wanted it to be. I viewed gaming on the iPod much as I do on my Macintosh, in that I didn’t buy a Mac to play games, but if there are games available, I’ll certainly play them. Unfortunately, developers just never put much thought into iPod games, and Apple didn’t seem interested in helping out.

The main problem, of course, is the scroll wheel. There are very few games that can be effectively controlled with a wheel, and developers just haven’t been able to work around that. Games such as Mini Golf, Vortex and Peggle are workable, but only because of the simple control schemes that mainly involve spinning in a circle. Okay. But why is Sonic the Hedgehog on the iPod? Bomberman? Pac Man? These are big name titles, sure, but trying to control them with a click wheel is an exercise in frustration and futility that only turns gamers away from the iPod.

Games for the iPhone are being developed specifically for the iPhone. Developers are excited about the touch screen and accelerometer, and are already putting them to good use. Obviously, developers didn’t have that excitement about the iPod’s click wheel. As a result, we got a mess of games with titles we recognize—Scrabble, Yahtzee, Pole Position, Pirates of the Caribberan(?!)—because that’s the only way people would buy them. Even EA, apparently recognizing no one wants to play pool on an iPod, threw their popular Sims franchise label on top of it in an effort to move some copies. They did the same with The Sims Bowling and The Sims DJ.

Actually, The Sims DJ goes in a direction that more games should have, in that it puts your music collection into the game. It’s not just background music while you play; rather, the gameplay is built around your music. It’s an original concept that could only work on the iPod. The same goes for iQuiz, which creates trivia games based on your own music. This is what more developers needed to do, instead of just throwing unplayable ports of cell phone games at us.

Or, someone could’ve given us an iPod game pad. I imagine if the market had been there, someone would have. I’m not a developer and know little of design, but I can’t imagine it would’ve been hard to put together a cradle in which the iPod classic and 3G nano would sit, placing a D-pad to the left of the click wheel and a few buttons to the right. The D-pad would take over the touch commands of the click wheel, and the buttons would take over the wheel and center button clicking functions. With that device, the games would be able to be played as they’re meant to, and the entire catalog would open to all iPod owners on a device combo no larger than a Nintendo DS.

Of course, the problem with such a device is that Apple updates the form factor of the iPod so frequently that it would have to be a wide open design to avoid becoming obsolete within a year or two. Plus, as I mentioned at the top of the article, people aren’t buying iPods for the games. The Nintendo DS and Sony PSP have that market covered, so it’s unlikely the type of person looking to play Sonic the Hedgehog would look to do so on an iPod.

And so, we’re back to game design. Developers need to put games on the iPod that work on the iPod, which is why I’m thrilled to see a company as huge as Square Enix getting into the mix with Song Summoner: The Unsung Heroes. Here’s a game that not only works with the click wheel (it’s not a perfect fit, but the turn-based strategy gameplay doesn’t require quick, precise control, and is therefore more forgiving), but that takes full advantage of the your music collection; the songs on your iPod actually become ”Tune Troopers.” How cool is that...building an army based on your music. I just added this game to my collection, and can’t wait to see what type of soldiers songs such as Queen’s “Ogre Battle” and “Vultan’s Theme (Attack of the Hawk Men)” give me. Or, for that matter, “Particle Man” from They Might Be Giants.

So, is there hope for iPod gaming, or is this too little, too late? I fear it’s the latter, but I hope Song Summoner does well enough to convince Square Enix to embrace the iPhone and iPod touch platforms. Support from big name developers and publishers will improve public perception within the gaming community, and that can only be good for sales. After all, showing friends Vortex on the iPod never convinced anyone to run out and buy one, but Super Monkey Ball could certainly have that effect.

Full Story » | Written by Kirk Hiner for Appletell. | Comment on this Article »


Read the article on AppleTell
Macworld

Review: Remote for iPhone and iPod touch

If you've been frustrated by Apple TV’s painfully-slow menu navigation, Apple’s new Remote program for the iPhone and iPod touch may be the answer.
Similar news about iPhone
TUAW

TUAW Review: Richard | Solo Smart Backup Battery for iPhone / iPod

If there's anything I've learned about the iPhone 3G since July 11th, it's that the battery life is horrible. If I'm just texting and making the occasional call, I can survive for a day, but if I try to play games or use 3G I know it's going to go to the dreaded red battery icon quickly.That's why there are a growing number of manufacturers who have extended battery packs for the iPhone on the market. For example, I looked at the Kensington Mini Battery Pack and Charger (US$49.99), but the website doesn't show that it works with the iPhone 3G. My next choice was the Richard | Solo Smart Backup Battery. This US$49.95 lithium-ion battery pack has saved me from running out of juice prematurely more than once! Read on for more information about this must-have sidekick for the iPhone 3G.Continue reading TUAW Review: Richard | Solo Smart Backup Battery for iPhone / iPodRead | Permalink | Email this | Comments
Similar news about Accessories

Macworld - iPhone and iPod case roundup: nanos...

We know that what you really hunger for are iPod and iPhone cases, so join us for this week's roundup as we look at three models.
08/01/08
Similar news about iPhone

Macworld - iPhone and iPod Case Roundup:...

In this week's case roundup, Dan Pourhadi looks at a couple cases for taking your iPhone and iPod classic with you when you work out.
06/06/08
Similar news about iPhone

Macworld - Remote lets you control iTunes from...

Apple's Remote application lets you take control of your iTunes library from your iPhone or iPod touch.
07/10/08
Similar news about iPhone

Yahoo! News Apple May Offer Remote Control App...

TechWeb - InformationWeek - The remote control application would presumably work via a Wi-Fi connection, since the iPhone and iPod Touch support the wireless technology.
06/27/08
Similar news about iPhone

Macworld - Original iPhones come back to life as...

What happens to old iPhones? They go to heaven—and become iPod touches.
07/12/08
Similar news about iPhone

AppleTell iPhone price; cheaper than an iPod...

Section: Apple, Apple News, Conferences, WWDC, iPod + iTunes, iPod touch, iPod, iPhone + Communications, iPhone, OriginalsAt only $199, is it more cost effective to buy an...
06/10/08
Similar news about iPhone
Your Ad Here
Macworld

iPod and iPhone Case Roundup: Working up a sweat

iPods are great for working out, but it always helps to have the right equipment. Here are four cases that let you give your iPod a run for its money.
Similar news about iPod
Macworld

iPod and iPhone case roundup: grab bag

We look at a holder for the original iPhone, a leather sleeve for the iPod classic, and a bag-strap pouch that fits all of Apple’s mobile gadgets.
Similar news about iPhone

iLounge Article: Does iPhone SDK mark the end...

When Apple announced the iPhone Software Development Kit in early March, game developers were nearly unanimous in praising the tools, iTunes-focused distribution methodology,...
03/25/08
Similar news about iPod

AppleInsider iPod on long road downhill as iPhone...

A new forecast has the iPod's influence on Apple dropping steadily over the next few years as the iPhone cannibalizes its sales and generates a halo around the Mac. In a new...
06/19/08
Similar news about iPhone

Macworld - VirusBarrier adds iPhone, iPod touch...

VirusBarrier x5 has been updated to support the iPhone and iPod touch, according to Intego.
07/17/08
Similar news about iPhone

Yahoo! News iPhone 3G Incompatible With Many iPod...

TechWeb - InformationWeek - Buyers of the iPhone 3G are complaining that the device can't be used with many of the pricey charging stations, sound docks, and other accessories...
07/14/08
Similar news about iPhone

Macworld - Where are the iPhone's iPod...

We've heard much of the new iPhone's networking, enterprise, and third-party features, but virtually nothing about improvements to its handling of media. Christopher Breen has...
06/12/08
Similar news about iPhone

AppleInsider Piper sees iPod boost; Sybase for...

Analysts at Piper Jaffray see iPod shipments on the rise and suggests Apple is bucking fears of a continued downturn. Also, Sybase is readying a native iPhone app, AT&T may...
05/20/08
Similar news about iPhone
AppleTell

Appletell Review: TuneCast Auto with ClearScan for iPhone and iPod

Section: iPod + iTunes, iPod Family, iPod Accessories, iPhone + Communications, iPhone Accessories, Features, Review Product: TuneCast Auto with ClearScan for iPhone and iPod Developer: Belkin Price: $79.99 Availability: Out now Rating: 7/10 Remember the iPod Classic? Hey, me too! Awesome! We should hang sometime! With all the warranted ferver surrounding the iPhone 3G and its little sidekick, the iPod Touch, the iPod that actually, you know, has enough disk space for a respectable music collection, has been nearly forgotten by the press and many Apple users...and sometimes, I think, even Apple itself. Thankfully, third party developers are well aware of the iPod Classic and its user base, and continue to release some pretty cool products. Such a product is Belkin’s TuneCast Auto with ClearScan for iPhone and iPod ($79.99). This is one of those FM transmitters that allows you to broadcast the music from your iPod to a clear FM channel on your car radio. I’ve reviewed many of these transmitters over at Applelinks, and none of them won me over to the process. FM transmission is faulty technology that rarely produces solid results. This is because it requires you to find an FM frequency on your car radio to which no broadcast is being sent, allowing the transmitter to take it over. If you live in a rural area, you’ll likely have luck with this. I live near Cleveland, Ohio, however, where it seems that just about every frequency is either taken or is floating around one that is. The end result is that I can hear my iPod, but I can also hear plenty of hiss and pops, and sometimes other songs. The other problem is that if you travel a good distance, you’re eventually going to have to find another station, as a frequency that’s open in one area may not be 50 miles down the highway. Most FM transmitters these days include presets, but that doesn’t help if you’re travelling someplace new, and you really shouldn’t be messing around with an FM transmitter while driving, anyway. This is where Belkin’s TuneCast Auto with ClearScan for iPhone and iPod stands out. With the push of a button, the ClearScan technology will automatically scan your radio for what it feels is your best FM option, then let you know with its large backlit display. Tune your radio to that frequency, and you’re set. The ClearScan is a bit shizophrenic, as it never seemed to settle on the same frequency twice in a row, but it eventually did pull in two stations on my commute that work fairly well, neither of which I would’ve tried on my own. Both were already getting a weak broadcast, but apparently weaker than the static I get on other channels. Someone will have to explain that to me later. And while you’re at it, explain to me why the signal is affected by the weather, and why cars and trucks driving by seemed to momentarily take over my transmission. For now, I’m just happy the ClearScan did its job. I tune to 88.5 when I leave my home near Akron, Ohio, then flip over to 88.5 when the interference on 88.3 starts as I approach Cleveland. Reverse that on the way home, and I’ve finally got acceptible iPod audio on my commute. It helps that the device comes with two programmable preset buttons. The Tunecast Auto allows you to broadcast in mono, which reportedly improves reception in congested areas. Perhaps my favorite addition, however, are the “Pro” settings that allow you to boost the audio level from the iPod. This is great, as previous FM transmitters were so weak that I had to crank my radio to hear the iPod. When turning off the car, that brief second where control would revert to the radio would blow out my eardrums and (worse) my speakers with music or static. TuneCast Auto allows me to play the iPod at the level of the radio, so I usually don’t need to mess with the volume. One thing to consider when looking at the TuneCast Auto is that it doesn’t come with any kind of holder. It’s just a device on a cable which plugs into your cigarette lighter/power source, so your iPod will sit loosely in the car. I actually prefer this, as I don’t want some stick rising in front to my dashboad panel, letting any would-be thieves know there’s expensive technology here for the taking. The TuneCast Auto cable can be easily tucked away and allows for easy access by both the driver and a passenger. Although the backlit display is legible in most circumstances, I found it hard to read when the sunlight was hitting it directly. Oh, and, Of course, your iPod will recharge as long as it’s plugged in. FM tranmission is still not the way to go if you can avoid it. But, if you don’t want to spend the money on an installed iPod interface, TuneCast Auto with ClearScan for iPhone and iPod is certainly one of the better options available. And having access to nearly 4,000 songs is worth any interference that should surface. Full Story » | Written by Kirk Hiner for Appletell. | Comment on this Article »
Similar news about iPod
AppleInsider

iPhone 3G to be in healthy supply as iPod touch supplies weaken

Apple should have ample stock of iPhone 3G when it touches down this month, according to analysts, who also note that Apple stands to make more from each device than once thought -- and that iPod touch stocks are continuing to run down ahead of a pos...
Similar news about iPhone

AppleTell iLounge releases iPod + iPhone book...

Section: iPod + iTunes, iTunes, iPod, iPhone + Communications, iPhone Accessories It can be frustrating when you purchase a device and don’t find the answers to the...
06/03/08
Similar news about iPhone

AppleTell AirRemote turns the iPhone, iPod...

Section: iPhone + Communications, iPhone Accessories, iPhone, iPhone SDK & AppsUsing a mobile phone as a remote control is nothing new. Most of the advanced Nokia handsets have...
06/17/08
Similar news about Wireless

Macworld - Troubleshooting iPhone and iPod touch...

Learn a few things you can try when experiencing issues with your iPhone or iPod touch running the 2.0.x software.
08/14/08
Similar news about iPhone

Macworld - iPhone and iPod case roundup

There are new iPod and iPhone cases available from various vendors.
07/22/08
Similar news about Accessories

Macworld - In defense of iPod gaming

Christopher Breen had some harsh words about the state of gaming on the iPod. Peter Cohen responds, pointing out the interesting titles on the iPod and how iPod game development...
04/28/08
Similar news about iPod

AppleTell Can Apple make the iPod touch...

Section: iPod + iTunes, iPod touch, iPhone + Communications, iPhone, Originals As we all know, Apple cut the price of the iPhone to $199, making the 8GB iPod touch now the...
06/14/08
Similar news about iPod

Webmaster